Fire & Ice Pizzeria & Creamery

This place was fantastic. Our family was in Buchanan Michigan and we were looking for a place that satisfied all of my kids requests. Half of them wanted pizza the other half wanted sandwiches or bready products. We looked online and this place stood out as a destination spot. The staff was very helpful and nice they did a great job of walking us through the ordering process after we told them that we would be eating both pizza and ice cream. We opted for four pizzas and four cups of ice cream for everyone to share. Everything was fantastic. In the back there's an activity space with ping pong foosball a playhouse and billiards for adults. This place is definitely going to be a destination spot when we come into Buchanan every summer to harvest peaches. And the pizza was absolutely phenomenal I highly recommend the margarita pizza.

First time visit on a Wednesday at 5 pm with two toddlers. They had plenty of kid food options (mini pizza, chicken nuggets, mac & cheese, grilled cheese sandwich, or PB&J) for $5 each. I upgraded for $3 more to include a drink and ice cream. The chicken on the pizza came shredded (which was unexpected) but I liked the crust and how it was cooked. My bbq chicken was a little bland overall but I still liked it. The syrup was out on the Sprite. The ice cream was delicious and fun to watch. Overall, the vibe/environment wasn't my style but it's perfect if you want a casual atmosphere for the kids to play while waiting for food and after eating. It was quite loud and there was a birthday party happening in the other room. The bathrooms were single, not stalls, so that could be problematic if one of my girls had to pee badly and it was in use. I was also a little concerned about the playhouse, the lights were out and the ladder wasn't age appropriate for all the kids squeezed in there, so that was a bit sketchy. Finally, the oldest employee was MAYBE 21 but most likely younger. The rest of the staff seemed 18 or under and annoyed overall. I would honestly order to-go in the future. Update 3/24: Visted for a second time on a Friday at 4:30 PM. The tequila lime pizza was awesome and it's so fun to watch the employees make the ice cream.. but the kids area is just too loud and uncontrolled for us. The employees were all really nice and helpful today and I will probably return in the future.

It was tasty! The pizza dough was a little doughier than some people may prefer, but I liked it. The barbecue sauce was delicious on the BBQ chicken pizza. I wish there had been a little bit more chicken. Pizza was done on time and ready for pickup.

Very surprised by this place - at first, it seemed like a somewhat run down pizza king or something. However, we were immediately greeted by some very friendly and helpful staff. We ordered pizzas, and a salad since they were sold out of gluten free crusts. However, being out of gluten free ended up not being an issue, because the salad was one of the best I have ever had. The pizzas were top quality too, not what you expect for that low of a price, these beat most fancy sit down Italian restaurants! Then - the ice cream! The two mad scientists working the liquid nitrogen were artists at their craft, amazing to watch and the results tasted as good as they looked! Don't miss going to this hidden gem of a place!

1st time visitors! Recently relocated to St. Joseph from Kentucky; and had heard positive reviews of Fire & Ice ( of course intrigued by the name ) so gave it a shot on a Saturday evening, around 7:30ish. Pizzas were awesome! Wait staff were awesome! Ice Cream we are still eating, but AWESOME!! SO, take the hint and check it out y'all..!!