Vinny Restaurant Pizza & Subs

We ordered pizza for the Super Bowl, I stopped in a few days earlier to order and pay and the person who helped me out front was SO nice and personable, she helped me get ordered and I actually had a friend pick-up before the party and they said the pizzas were hot and ready right on time (not sitting for a long time) and these were SOME OF THE BEST pizza we’ve ever had!!! The crust was perfect, sauce was great and the cheese and pepperoni were generous toppings! I would recommend Vinny’s and we will be having dinner here more often! Thanks Vinny’s !!

Best Italian restaurant in Carlisle. People come for the pizza and boli's, but the Vinny's salad is the real winner. Custom boli's and everything can be eaten in or taken to go.

The food is good if you can afford it. I got an Italian sub, mozzarella sticks and a drink and it cost $22. That's about the most I'd be willing to pay for a top quality lunch, but it turns out you can get the same thing at George's for a lot less money, and the quality is better. Avoid Vinnie unless you have money to burn.

Ive been coming to this place since I was little, when it used to be called genovas! I’ve always had a pleasant experience here, but lets talk about the FOOD! You honestly can’t go wrong here, anything is gonna be awesome. My favorite thing… the bread. Best bread in Carlisle IMO. The pizza is also awesome. I live in philly for school, so Im not able to get it as frequently as I’d like. But everytime I come home, I BEG my dad to take us here. Its my comfort food!!

Stopped here for dinner before heading to the Ice Festival for dinner after reading the reviews. Hubby and I split the special steak and it was delicious. The onions and peppers were tender and not at all greasy and they were very generous with the mushrooms too and lots of melted mozzarella and the steak was flavorful rib eye. The rolls are clearly made fresh daily and I made sure to eat every last crumb, a great sub needs an awesome roll and Vinny's are top notch. The basket of fries is enough for 2, crispy on the outside and you can tell they change the grease daily. The only suggestion I have would be to offer a large size soda, they only have 1 size and it's not very big. The dining area was clean and brightly lit with lots of booths, friendly staff and plenty of parking in their large lot. We'll definitely be back when we're in the area, best sub I've had in a long time