Rustic Tavern

I go to the Rustic Tavern 4 times a year for the last 15 years as its my go to when attending the Carlisle Car shows. Bartender Jerry has been there since mid 2000's i believe and remembers my name and what my favorite beer is. The entire staff is very friendly and personable and the food is the best in town! If you leave hungry its not their fault!

This place was great . After driving for close to 12 hours we got to our hotel and headed here to eat . We got there around 9pm and they closed at 10. The got us right in and the service was great . I think our persons name was Amanda . She took our order and the food was done very quickly . Very large plates of food as well ! What a great meal after a very long day . Thank you

Crab cakes are DELICIOUS!!! And chocolate chip Cannolis Waitresses we're super nice and very good service! I would recommend the Rustic Tavern 5 STAR ?????

Food was quite good, especially the seafood options. The Zorba's Flatbread was super tasty with well-cooked shrimp. Sweet chili salmon was also cooked perfectly and very tasty. I recommend the mixed-grille for trying a few different options and sides. Service was very good, especially for a busy night. It was a crowded Wednesday night, but we didn't wait too long for a table. I wish they took reservations for smaller parties, but I understand why they don't. 4.5/5

We are from out of town and after reviewing Google, this felt like the best option for lunch. We were not at all disappointed. The food was delicious. The service was exceptional. We will definitely stop in again when we’re in the area!!