Sully's Irish Pub

Our second visit to this local landmark, service is great, food is good, menu somewhat limited. Dining outside, the only downside was the flies, which were quite a challenge. My companion enjoyed her rueben, which I understand was tasty, and the portion was large enough half went home. My cheesesteak was ok, fries above average. Pro Move: free parking in the back keeps you off busy Main Street in Middletown.

Wings and steamed shrimp were fantastic! Flatbread was okay, could use a little more flavor. The service though was lacking. Three bartenders, one manager, (maybe, he was drinking beer at the bar) an owner (maybe) and a child behind the bar and we still had to ask for help. Again, great food, maybe they will focus on their service.

Definitely will return. Great food, my wife had the holy reuben batman (yes that's the name of it) and fries and I had the pork schnitzel, mashed potatoes with bacon, and sauerkraut. We also got wings but not so great IMHO. Drinks were also of great caliber.

The food is really good and the drinks are nice. Love the history, the decor, and the staff. The speakers for the football game were pretty loud so it made it hard to have a laid back conversation. However if you are looking for a fun pub with good food to enjoy the game with friends this is probably the perfect place for you.

Honestly, half the time, they give you a 5 star service and great food, but then you have times where your food isn't evenly cooked, cold, and the cream of crab soup has been sitting so long its developed a film...