James Angelo's Underground Pizza

Great little pizza spot! Floor is slippery with flour dust, there's a giant table labeled "The Godfather" and they have pebble ice. Dude making pizza is no nonsense, little conversation but solid delivery. Pizza was fantastic! Check them out!

The best pizza in Hawaii! Worth a trip to Waimea for homemade crust made daily. The owner is James, originally from Boston. You may get to see him tossing the dough up in the air! It’s a nice chewy and crunchy crust, it’s really perfection. Toppings and cheese are generous portions and of course the sauce is delicious.

Awesome little place coming from the North through Waimea. After a long day and drive through Volcano’s National Park, this place hit the spot. ***CASH ONLY*** The two large Boston-style pizzas were delicious and filling. They also have a sonic crushed ice maker for their drinks! Great value and pricing for the whole family and there’s a few tables to sit inside. Ample parking on the side. Will definitely return!

Stopped by on the way back Hilo side after a day at Hapuna. The food was reasonably priced for how delicious it was. It was also ran solely by one man who was attentive and kind. I got the Philly Cheesesteak, and my friends got the Kalua Pork Pizza, Plain Spaghetti and Hot Wings. No complaints all around - it really hit the spot! I'll be back!

Good, low-key pizza and Italian food restaurant featuring Boston/Massachusetts hand-tossed pizza. Excellent food. Friendly service. Cash only. BYOB.