American Pie Pizzeria

That is the best Pizza in Barnsville. That will be my Christmas meal ! For sure ! Nice customer service too. Again really good fresh Pizza ! 100%

Pizza is some of the best around. The dough is great, not too thick and not too thin. The toppings are always plentiful - something other Pizza places tend to skimp on. Love their Greek Salad and "Betty Salad." Always seem fresh and taste great. They are a little more on the "expensive side" of local options, but you pay for what you get. The food here is worth it to me. Lastly, the cinnamon butter balls....they're sooooo good if you have a sweet tooth and don't mind the extra calories. There's a drive up window too, which is convenient for picking up call in orders.

Had never eaten here before.. the pizza is really good. You can tell it's a handmade pizza as the crust was uneven not like the big chain style crusts. The ingredients were plentiful and staff was very nice. We will be back!!

Food is decent. Not a ton of options in the area. My husband and his friends like it. I’d probably like it more if they paid attention in the kitchen... Ordering something vegetarian (veggie wrap or asking specifically for no bacon on my pizza) apparently means sprinkle ALL the bacon on my food. 2/3 visits this has happened to me. I’m reaching my limit. Not to mention during this last visit my wrap came out 13 minutes after my husbands pizza… I had to check to see if they forgot to make it.

Great pizza and butterballs when they remember to put the butter on them. Food is good but the service is trash