Castaways

We drive from Westville Indiana to eat here. I enjoy he friendly faces and excellent service we receive every time. You get Soup and Salad, entree and dessert with full dinners. Can’t beat the prices for all you receive.

Great host, server, and staff! Was very shocked and impressed that we could get soup AND salad AND dessert with the entrees! All that food for very little price! So affordable! Portions were huge for the entree’s! Huge selection on the menu! Carol is a hard worker, presents herself well, and cares about the customer! She does a great job leading the team! Both servers today, (Christmas Eve) were bubbly and great with all of the people! Good to see the place busy!

Castaways is a sweet little diner with delicious food and really good mimosas. The staff was attentive and really friendly. We will definitely be back!

We will Never return!! Issues with our meals Every time we've gone, and simply Terrible food the last time we went. Last time a few weeks ago, the female manager apologized and made it right. Came back today with the gift card she gave us last time. Went to order food and was told they ran out of the gravy for the special breakfast skillet. Understandable, so I asked if they could sub it for something and gave a few suggestions. Our waiter checked with the male in charge. I was told no substitutions unless it was for their other gravy. Brown gravy and chicken gravy do not go on a breakfast skillet as a substitute for breakfast sausage gravy. I asked instead can you lower the price since I don't want to pay for an ingredient you don't have. Our waiter again asked and I was told no. At that point I paid for my drinks with the gift card, left a tip for the waiter, and left. The gentleman checking us out asked if I wanted the manager or owner. I informed him that I tried already, and it was too late, that I paid and was leaving and Never returning.

The food and service was amazing. Our servers, Hannah and Yasmine, were very nice and patient with our large group. We were seated very quickly, and our food came out in a timely manner. Definitely coming back and would recommend!