Blackbeard’s Tavern

We sat at the bar. Our bartender Alisie was fantastic. She took very good care of us We had peel and eat shrimp, the vegetarian pizza with ham and pepperoni (cause that’s what we like) and a Greek salad. Zero complaints. In fact all we’re really, really delicious. Old Fashioned’s we’re on point and the pours of Chardonnay did not disappoint. If vacationing in Bath we will definitely return. Don’t miss out on this opportunity to enjoy foods in a comfortable and kind local’s environment.

Can I give zero stars? That’s what would accurately describes the experience. Tried calling order in for take out. After over 15 calls going unanswered, finally decided to physically go to place order. Not busy. When I asked wait staff about call in order they said ‘sometimes we unplug the phone if we get busy’. No automated note or anything just silences on their end and lets it ring on customer side. Paid $20 for what would be considered small or personal pizza at most places. Staff overall was apathetic and untrained. Awful experience overall. Minimal changes could increase experience exponentially but does not seem to be a priority of ownership.

It’s not like there pizzas are cheap. Paid $31 for a large pizza. When I got home . The pizza was burnt. Can’t believe black beards put that in a pizza box.. I have recently purchased 4 pizza’s from Black Beards since. All pizzas have been extremely good and tasty. My hats off to the pizza chef!

Food was honestly awful. Way over priced for what it was. Chicken sandwiches were way over fried, and you could tell they came from a frozen food service bag not made there on site. Meatloaf was not fresh at all…was more like Salisbury steak. The “moonshine bbq sauce” literally looked like brown gravy. The things that you could tell they actually made there fresh were really good though! The sweet potato waffle fries were great although a couple of the Thicker ones were undercooked. The baked potato salad….best potato salad I’ve ever had! Seems like the only things they actually make fresh there are their sides. However….the waitress was great. Very attentive and sweet. It was not her fault the food quality was lacking. The atmosphere was nice enough. Looks like they definitely recently remodeled which was nice. Overall though honestly just not worth the money you will spend. Drive a little further and spend your money elsewhere.

My husband and I stayed in Bath over the holidays, and I can't tell you the number of times we went to eat there and placed take out. The pizza is fantastic, wings are perfectly coated in sauce and crispy, and the bar tender is sweet and attentive.