Amanda's Bakery Co.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED, Amanda did a great job for the cake I ordered, and the price she quote me was worth it .get a custom cake done I shopped around and everyone was expensive but she gave-me a quote which suited my budget so didn’t ask anything and hoped the cake to be good. I had custom jungle safari theme cake , and it came out beautiful for my first sons birthday. The cake tasted delicious it was just “the right “amount of sweetness she had , I mean Amazing???? never had a cake taste sooo good like this from a bakery . I am Soo happy I chose them. THANK YOU SOO MUCH FOR MAKING IT SPECIAL???? you all are amazing. Please refer picture for reference., Amanda bakery only lacked one thing was delivery . They don’t deliver ????we had to pick it up.THANK YOU

My daughters Mother in law ordered cookies from Amanda’s Bakery for my daughters baby shower. When we came to Amanda’s we came with just a picture we found off the internet of what we wanted. Amanda’s needed a little time to come up with a sample for us but we were blown away when we saw the design and of course the fantastic taste of the cookie. The cookies were even better then we could have expected. Just so beautiful! We ordered them for her shower (which is today) and we couldn’t be happier. Thank you Amada’s for helping make my daughters baby shower even more so special.

This is such a cute little bakery in the heart of Bay Shore! I found it through google because I was looking for a good bakery and Amanda's Bakery had a 4.8/5, raving reviews, and beautiful photos so I knew I needed to try it. It is on main street so the parking in front is a little limited but there is a very convenient parking lot in the back along with side street parking. The atmosphere is adorable and is very inviting for a cup of joe or splitting your favorite pastry! My cousin and I got traditional cheesecake, 2 cakes pops, and a smores bite (I believe is what it is called). The cake pops were great because they were not overly sweet! The smores bite was absolutely delicious and definitely my second favorite. However, the cheesecake was the fan favorite! Even my mom started sneaking in bites because we could not stop talking about how great it was! I will definitely be coming back for more! 10/10 recommend!

Amanda and her staff are simply the best! I gave her an idea and told her to run with it! Everything in my order was DELICIOUS and my guests could not stop raving about the cake! Definitely will continue to support her business for years to come!

Spent a couple hours in this cute bake shop when a meeting was postponed. What a great detour! All their baked goods look incredible. They clearly have a solid customer base for cakes, as people were either in and out during my whole time placing orders, or they were calling orders in on the phone. I had a little snack; an edible cookie dough, doughnut, and just a black coffee. All very good!